This is my first post on this form and, honestly, one of the few threads I've read completely through in a long time. I sympathize with much of what has already been said mainly because I too have been an avid RPG PNP turned MMORG player.
To tell you the truth, EQ2 has been the closest experience to my fond memorize as a (younger) PNP enthusiast. In my opinion, what's great about EQ2 is not what 'uber' items you can acquire, or how many platinum you can brag about, or even what level you have achieved. My fondest memories in EQ2 have always been with my guildies or grouping with my actual friends who happen to play EQ2. If it were not for playing with my friends, what would be the point of playing MMORG? If your actions don't impact 'real' people than you're basically playing a computer game with amazing AI (i.e. human players that are essential nonames).
In short, if your tired of EQ2, have no motivation for questing or looting, then talk to a friend or two and have them join you in EQ2. I think you'll find new found enjoyment.
